Spin the bottle - Jeff the Killer X reader.

You spun the bottle and watched as it spun round and round and round and round and- it slowly stopped. You slowly look up and see a boy wearing a white hoodie with long black hair and a carved smile. Your eyes widen… Jeff…

“great…” you mumble.

He heard it and replied. “Like, I want to do this..I was forced.” He said looking away.

When you met the creepypastas, all had been very nice to you except one…Jeff the killer, one of the people who made your life hell. You and Jeff never really got along since then, you tried to be nice to him before, even did what he wanted, but his stupid attitude just will never change… once a killer always a killer…you thought as you sighed.

“okay guys, what do you want them to do?”  Splendorman asked the other creepypastas.

They looked each other while grinning then started to suggest, Touch her boobs, RAPE, Kiss! , Just hug Already!

“Well the rules say: you both should Hug lovingly!”  Slenderman suggested.

“NO WAY!” You and Jeff said at the same time. You look at each other but then looked away quickly.

“oops, your five seconds is up! Now you both better kiss or…” He smiled Wickedly.

“That’s even WORSE!” You shouted.

“Would you rather make love, in front of us?” BEN said.

…

They we’re all waiting for you and Jeff to kiss our hearts out. They all stare intensely.

You and Jeff blush really hard, looking at each other… “I-I’m not sure…” you say..

“Just do it already!” Laughing Jack says, becoming impatient.

You look at Jeff, glaring at him. He smirks. “Yeah, sure let’s do it.” He said mockingly.

“What…NO!” You complained.

“but not here…” He said, ignoring your complain and looked around for the perfect spot.

“That won’t be fair, we wanna watch you…” BEN made a kissing action.

“I am so gonna video tape this.” Laughing Jack says, taking out a camera that came out of nowhere.

“NO.” you both say firmly.
... ... ...

Jeff sighed and pulled you on a corner, where they can’t see you but is still ear-reach. You can hear them groan and you chuckled lightly.

You look back at Jeff who is now, nose to nose near to you.

“Let’s make this quick.” He whispers.

“wait, we aren't gonna actua-“ You stopped as his lips pressed against yours. You we’re shocked by the impact and suddenness that made you moan a little. You regretted it, but couldn't stop it from escaping.

He parted his lips to catch your breaths, you both just look at each other. The way he looks at you made you blush more.

“oh? In love with me now?” he grinned.

“o-of course not!” you still can’t believe he kissed you.

He laughed. And kissed you again, you close your eyes and decided to just let it be.

You both kissed in sync with each other.

You thought Jeff was just doing it, to embarrass you more and use this moment to tease you. But little did you know that Jeff was enjoying every moment of what was happening.

He stopped and moved to your neck, kissing and licking you hungrily, trying to find you sweet spot.

“Jeff, No…Ahhh~” You moan as he found it. Despite that you hate him and all the terrible thing he has done to you, you forgot all about it and just let Jeff do what he wanted.. but then…

‘click’ ‘click’. Something was flashing beside us. you look over and see Laughing Jack carrying a camera and BEN having a major nosebleed.

“What?!..Jeff, Stop!... CAMERA!” You push him away.

He looked dazzled and confused but then saw the problem and Sudden anger flashed through his unblinking eyes.

“YOU SCUMS!” He  shouts.

Laughing jack and BEN runs away laughing.

Jeff began to follow them but stopped. “I’ll be back for you, I’m not done yet.”

You flinch and blush.

Then he was off chasing after the two idiots.

This is gonna be a long night…you thought as You sit back at the circle and see everyone looking at you…grinning

“what?” you ask.

“oh..nothing”. Masky said.

You huffed.

“Enjoyed yourself?” Hoodie asked amused. Masky elbowed him playfully, mouthing a ‘shhh’.

“oh, shut up.” You blush looking away, thinking of what Jeff is gonna do to you…

--Time skip--

You were walking along the corridor, it was late at night but you couldn't go back to sleep. You shivered as you feel someone behind you. you look back and see nothing. You started to walk when 2 strong hands pulled you in a room.

You were about to scream when the person kissed you...it was Jeff..

"would you really think, I wouldn't keep what I said?" He laughed maniacally and started to undress you...Pushing you in his bed. that night you grew a bond and made serious loving too.